Enforcement of CC&Rs

Condominium and homeowner association CC&Rs are, in many ways, similar to contracts. If one party breaches the terms of the contract, the other party may seek the help of the legal system for damages or to require the breaching party to fulfill their obligations. Most CC&Rs allow the community association to enforce the covenants and promises found in the governing documents. The association does this through its elected board of directors.  But does the association have an obligation to enforce the CC&Rs? In most cases, the answer is yes.

A careful look at the CC&Rs will determine who has enforcement authority and whether enforcement is an obligation or a right. Some governing documents require a vote of the owners prior to taking certain enforcement actions.  Other CC&Rs (where there may not be an association) require individual owners to enforce all of the provisions of the governing documents.

The question of whether or not an association may use legal proceedings to enforce its CC&Rs depends on “standing.”  Standing, in a legal sense, means that the party to the litigation has a stake or interest in the dispute, as well as the capacity to sue.  In Oregon and Washington, state law grants community associations standing and authority to enforce covenants through legal action.

Oregon law specifically authorizes community associations to initiate or intervene in matters relating to the enforcement of governing documents:

[A] homeowners association may…initiate or intervene in litigation or administrative proceedings in its own name and without joining the individual owners in the following:

      (A) Matters relating to the collection of assessments and the enforcement of governing documents[.] (ORS 94.630(e)(A))

In Washington, homeowners associations have similar authority. Unless prohibited by the governing documents, an association may:

Institute, defend, or intervene in litigation or administrative proceedings in its own name on behalf of itself or two or more owners on matters affecting the homeowners' association, but not on behalf of owners involved in disputes that are not the responsibility of the association[.] (RCW 64.38.020)

Before an association takes legal action to enforce its governing documents, ask these questions:

1. Would levying fines against a violating owner be more effective?

2. Does the cost of litigation outweigh enforcement through a lawsuit?

3. Does the association have an affirmative duty to enforce the covenant?

4. Is enforcement of the issue more appropriately handled between individual owners?

5. Is alternative dispute resolution an option to resolve the violation?

How Covenants Are Created

Covenants are promises made by the purchaser of property to do (or not do) something upon the land. The most common form of covenants are CC&Rs: covenants, conditions and restrictions.  Almost always in writing, covenants may attach to the property in several different ways: 1. Deed

When the purchaser of property takes title, it is usually done so through a written and recorded deed.  The deed itself may contain covenants preventing the purchaser from certain activities, like mining for minerals or creating a nuisance affecting adjacent land owners.

2. Declaration

A declaration refers to a "declaration of covenants, conditions and restrictions"--the full title of CC&Rs. The declaration subjects multiple lots or parcels in a subdivision or community to the same set of covenants prior to the developer or "declarant" conveying the first lot in the community.  Often, the declaration is incorporated or referenced in the deeds to individual purchasers.  In most states, the recording of the declaration is sufficient without having to incorporate or reference the declaration in each individual deed.

3. Plat

Similar to a declaration, a developer may place covenants on the recorded plat of the community. The plat is a graphical depiction of the lot lines, roads, and common property.  For condominiums, the plat will also show the elevation profile of the units and common elements.  Covenants contained in plats are typically noted in the narrative portion of the plat or referenced on the affected parcels.

Governing Document Primer - Condominiums and HOAs

The term “governing documents” refers to a host of documents, some of which are recorded, some which are filed with the state, and others are merely distributed to owners. In general, governing documents include: the Declaration/CC&Rs, Bylaws, Plat, Articles of Incorporation, and Rules/Regulations/Resolutions. Understand that there is a hierarchy to these documents. For example, the board cannot adopt a rule or regulation that conflicts with provisions in the CC&Rs. See the attached charts to better understand the hierarchy:

Oregon

Washington

Let’s discuss each:

1. Plat

The plat map is the graphical depiction of the community. For planned community subdivisions, the plat is a birds-eye view of lot lines, easements, roads, and other property interests. Condominium plats are slightly different. Condo plats include the elevation drawings of the structures, and show the boundaries between the units, limited common elements, and general common elements. Often, plats will have notations regarding ownership of common areas, maintenance obligations, and references to the CC&Rs. Plats are recorded with the county recorders office.

2. Declaration/CC&Rs

Think of the CC&Rs as the constitution of the community. When you purchase property in a community association, you do so subject to the conditions in the CC&Rs and the other governing documents. The CC&Rs usually include: a description of the property, what you can and can’t do on your lot or on common property, the authority to assess regular dues, provisions related to insurance, and who is to maintain, repair and replace property throughout the community. Like the plat, CC&Rs are also recorded with the county recorder.

3. Articles of Incorporation

This document establishes the corporate structure for the community association. Typically, the association incorporates as a nonprofit corporation. Incorporation can provide protection against liability, allow the association to hold title to property, and simplify the process of securing insurance policies. Articles of incorporation are filed with the secretary of state.

4. Bylaws

The bylaws are the operating guidelines for the association and typically include: meeting requirements, quorum requirements, number of officers and directors, and provisions governing books and records. Usually, the bylaws are recorded in the county recorders office.

5. Rules/Regulations/Resolutions

This is a broad category, and refers to those documents that are typically adopted by the board of directors without a vote of the owners (note: some associations may have owner approval requirements). Examples include: architectural guidelines, collections resolutions, enforcement procedures, and house rules. These documents are not recorded, which is why it is critical that owners receive and are on notice of these documents. Keep resolutions simple, be sure to cite to the authority for adopting the rule or regulation, and make sure owners know the reasons for adoption.